Please complete the “Reviewer’s Comments” form by the due date to the receiving editorial office. This option should only be chosen if the reviewer is completely satisfied with all aspects of the paper and no improvements can be made. Shop & Discover This means you must not share them or information about the review with anyone without prior authorization from the editor.Finally, we take the opportunity to thank you sincerely on behalf of the journal, editors and author(s) for the time you have taken to give your valuable input to the article.Copyright © 2020 Elsevier, except certain content provided by third partiesCookies are used by this site. Please never hesitate to contact the receiving editorial office with any questions or concerns you may have. CiteScore values are based on citation counts in a range of four years (e.g. The editor will weigh all views and may call for another opinion or ask the author for a revised paper before making a decision.
Most journals require ethical approval by the author’s host organization. Your review will be managed via an Elsevier submission system such as Editorial Manager. If you have agreed to review a paper but will no longer be able to finish the work before the deadline, …
Once you are ready to submit your report, follow the instructions in the email The editor ultimately decides whether to accept or reject the article.
Reviewers rarely choose this option in the first round. Please check journal-specific guidelines for such cases (available from the journal’s homepage, If you don’t spot any major flaws, take a break from the manuscript, giving you time to think. It will also aid the author and allow them to improve their manuscript. For qualitative research make sure that a systematic data analysis is presented and sufficient descriptive elements with relevant quotes from interviews are listed in addition to the author’s narrative.Once you are satisfied that the methodology is sufficiently robust, examine any data in the form of figures, tables, or images. To access the paper and deliver your review, click on the link in the invitation email you received which will bring you to the submission/reviewing system. Giving your overall opinion and general observations of the article is essential.
Once production of your article has started, you can track the status of your article via
Elsevier journals use different submission systems so there is no one generic login link. Finished reviews of an article should be completed within two weeks. Your recommendation regarding an article will be strongly considered when the editors make the final decision, and your thorough, honest feedback will be much appreciated. If you do not think you can complete the review within this time frame, please let the editor know and if possible, suggest an alternate reviewer. To decline or learn more, visit our We are always looking for ways to improve customer experience on Elsevier.com. Exceptions to the last rule are sometimes made in case of strongly conflicting reviews, where the reviewers … Please feel free to recommend alternate reviewer.
Consider the article from your own perspective. About Elsevier questionnaire) or other instructions for how to structure your feedback. Sign in to view your account details and order historyBefore you accept or decline an invitation to review, consider the following questions:Respond to the invitation as soon as you can (even if it is to decline) – a delay in your decision slows down the review process and means more waiting for the author.
Products & Solutions